1. Case Studies
  2. Tuvell v. IBM
  3. Tuvell v. IBM Record

Tuvell v. IBM Record

Tuvell v. IBM ⸻ Story │ Record │ Discussion

Files
Petition for Writ of Certiorari (PetWritCert), with Required Appendix (ReqApx) and Addendum (PetWritAdd)1.53 MB
Petition for Writ of Certiorari, Optional Appendix (OptApx)18.71 MB
First Supplemental Brief (re Judicial Misconduct), with Appendix341.57 KB
Second Supplemental Brief (re Judicial Misconduct), with Appendix248.29 KB
Petition for Rehearing of PetWritCert (PetWritReh)2.4 MB
Judicial Misconduct, Criminal Complaints (Letter)1.69 MB
Criminal Complaint for Judicial Misconduct (Suggested)329.72 KB
Judicial Twilight Zone (Essay)1.08 MB
Tolan-v-Cotton (Annotated)123.26 KB
FRCP LR56.1 D.Mass (Annotated)39.46 KB
PSOF-Exclusion Table (Unabridged, Juxtaposed)519.73 KB
Criminal Complaint for Judicial Misconduct (Filed)2.81 MB
Judicial Misconduct: Appeal; Third Complaint; Objection/Motion/Proposal (Cover Letter)231.84 KB
Judicial Misconduct Appeal, Petition for Review (PetRev)226.58 KB
Judicial Misconduct Objection/Motion/Proposal251.62 KB
Judicial Misconduct Third Complaint526.63 KB
Judicial Council Opinion, Annotated (JCOpAnn)582.22 KB
Judicial Council Appendix, JCApx (Exh.A-EE, pg.1-844)22.15 MB
Judicial Council Appendix, JCApx (Exh.FF-PP, pg.845-1149)56.05 MB
Judicial Conference Cover Letter225.7 KB
Appeal Joint Appendix, AplJApx (vol.I, Exh.1-9, pg.1-231)5.38 MB
Appeal Joint Appendix, AplJApx (vol.II, Exh.1-67, pg.232-1053)53.11 MB
Appeal Joint Appendix, AplJApx (vol.II, Exh.68-118, pg.1054-1449)52.08 MB
Appeal Joint Appendix, AplJApx (vol.III)3.84 MB
Internal IBM Complaints35.49 MB
Calendar of Major Events494.72 KB
Mandel Phone Call (Audio)15.98 MB
Mandel Phone Call (Transcript)663.89 KB
DMemo (Annotated)625.69 KB
Defendant’s Affadavit in Support (with Exhibits)16.17 MB
Appellate Oral Argument (Audio)14.75 MB
Appellate Oral Argument (Transcript, Annotated)520.45 KB
Appeal Petition for Rehearing, with Annotations (PetReh)457.18 KB
Supreme Court Docket #16-343768.5 KB
Denial of Petition for Writ of Certiorari43.41 KB
Denial of Petition for Writ of Certiorari Rehearing43.33 KB
IBM Business Conduct Guidelines (BCG)1.33 MB
IBM Concerns & Appeals (C&A)25.71 KB
Complaint of Judicial Misconduct (Barron), Acknowledgement52.93 KB
Judicial Council Appeal, Acknowledgement55.23 KB
Judicial Conference Emergency Motion, Receipt950.12 KB
DOJ Office of Inspector General, Complaint236.97 KB
DOJ Office of Inspector General, Reply29.75 KB
Correspondence with Criminal Division of DOJ97.03 KB
Email to JudCoun, JudConf, DOJ/FBI/PIN, re New Website (and New Book)71.36 KB
Complaint (First Amended)2.68 MB
Factual Background101.02 KB
PSOF (Plaintiff's Statement of Facts), Supreme Court Version192.62 KB
PSOF (Plaintiff's Statement of Facts), Original Version240.78 KB
PSOF-Exclusion Table, Abridged73.41 KB
PSOF-Exclusion Table, Unabridged77.51 KB
Narrative/Writing Exposure Therapy for PTSD212.15 KB
Expert Report10.9 MB
Docket Sheet141.53 KB
DSOF (Defendant's Statement of Facts)179.4 KB
ApltBrief (Appellant Brief)528.42 KB
ApleBrief (Appellee Brief)393.08 KB
DMemo (Defendant’s Memorandum in Support)299.22 KB
PMemo (Plaintiff’s Memorandum in Opposition)207.77 KB
RespDSOF (Plaintiff’s Response to DSOF)327.1 KB
RespPSOF (Defendant’s Response to PSOF)291.41 KB
RepPMemo (Defendant’s Reply to PMemo)185.82 KB
District Court Oral Argument (Transcript)96.57 KB
District Court Opinion/Decision (and Order)249.08 KB
District Court Opinion/Decision (and Order), Supreme Court Version197.27 KB
District Court Judgment71.63 KB
District Court Judgment, Supreme Court Version30.07 KB
Notice of Appeal67.23 KB
RepApleBrief (Plaintiff’s Reply to Appellee’s Brief)389.15 KB
Appellate Decision/Opinion (Original Version)164.74 KB
Appellate Decision/Opinion (Supreme Court Version)45.22 KB
Appellate Judgment (Original Version)98.3 KB
Appellate Judgment (Supreme Court Version)26.46 KB
PetReh (Appellate Petition for Rehearing)225.79 KB
PetReh Endnotes186.29 KB
Appellate Rehearing Denial (Original Version)35.97 KB
Appellate Rehearing Denial (Supreme Court Version)28.57 KB
Tips for Petition of Certiorari70.07 KB
Petition for Certiorari, Getting Your Foot in the Door107.63 KB
Rise and Fall of Plausibility Pleading968.75 KB
Note on FRCP 60(b) Sua Sponte245.05 KB
BC Law School Interview of Judge Barron1.47 MB
N.Y. Times v. U.S. (Including “Secret” U.S. Drone Memo)2.36 MB
Lawyer (Barron) and Kill List Memo (PDF)1.33 MB
Lawyer (Barron) and Kill List Memo (PNG)1.13 MB
Goebbels (mis-)Quote1.27 MB
Judicial Council Opinion (JCOp)374.04 KB
Tolan-v-Cotton94.79 KB
Motion for Summary Judgment96.62 KB
Judicial Council Opinion #2 (JCOp2)398.45 KB
Judicial Council Review Opinion438.5 KB
Constitutional Crisis Letter207.31 KB
Judicial Conference Committee Petition372.89 KB
Judicial Conference Committee Petition, Email version71.68 KB
Judicial Conference Committee Petition, Fixes115.38 KB
Letter to Transparency International352.33 KB
Netezza (Now IBM) Website Home Page1.04 MB
Email, On Judicial Bullshit127.29 KB
Frankfurt, On Bullshit105.45 KB
Kolber, Supreme Judicial Bullshit (Near Final Draft)281.54 KB
Email, Complaint About Acknowledgement, 1794.65 KB
Email, Complaint About Acknowledgement, 2252.34 KB
Email, Complaint About Acknowledgement, 3256.32 KB
Oxford Research Guide to English Law74.86 KB
Richmond Newspapers v. Virginia3.56 MB
Oakes, Davies, Justice Must Be Seen To Be Done683.99 KB
Kolber, Supreme Judicial Bullshit371.96 KB
Posner, Side-by-Side Comparison, Brief255.61 KB
Posner, Side-by-Side Comparison, Story190.38 KB
Docket Sheet, updated107.81 KB
Complaint (Original/Verified)2.79 MB
Spektor, Zuckerman, Raise or Waive/Forfeit227.78 KB
Email to U.S. Courts, Nov 30 201874.58 KB
Webform to U.S. Courts, Nov 30 20181.38 MB
Webform Letter to AOC (Judicial Conference), Apr 2 20191.63 MB
Email Letter to AOC (Judicial Conference), Apr 2 2019337.41 KB
U.S. Mail Letter to AOC (Judicial Conference), Apr 2 20191.59 MB
Filing Judicial Misconduct Complaint177.48 KB
AOC Info 1268.2 KB
AOC Info 296.25 KB
Final Criminal Complaint390.79 KB
Sperino, Thomas, Unequal Introduction945.04 KB
Reeves v. Sanderson Plumbing97.82 KB
AOC Phone Call, Apr 2 2019 (a)2.02 MB
AOC Phone Call, Apr 2 2019 (b)50.32 MB
AOC Phone Call, Apr 4 2019 (a)1.63 MB
AOC Phone Call, Apr 5 2019 (a)1.39 MB
AOC Phone Call, Apr 5 2019 (b)2.09 MB
AOC Phone Call, Apr 5 2019 (c)40.64 MB
AOC Phone Call, Apr 15 2019 (a)10.62 MB
AOC Phone Call, Apr 16 2019 (a)1.51 MB
AOC Phone Call, May 24 2019 (a)2.37 MB
AOC Phone Call, May 31 2019 (a)2.51 MB
AOC Phone Call, May 31 2019 (b)1.22 MB
Lelling Indicts Mass. Judge89.29 KB
Lelling Complaint, with Exhibits1.33 MB
Lelling Addendum275.74 KB
Lelling Politically Motivated59.62 KB
USPS Tracking, Jun 5 20191.11 MB
USPS Tracking, May 15 20193.08 MB
USPS Tracking, Jun 8 20191.1 MB
Beiner, When Courts Run Amuck151.54 KB
Lelling Letter 1819.93 KB
Sperino & Thomas, Unequal Podcast14.41 MB
Lelling Letter 22.55 MB
Lelling Continues Lying123.55 KB
Lelling Continues Lying, mail8.32 MB
Lelling Continues Lying, fixes472 bytes
Lelling Continues Lying, USPS Tracking1.1 MB
OIG Letter, Jun 14 2019718.09 KB
OIG Reply, Jul 5 201977.46 KB
Lawfare, The Law of Lying (PDF)143.51 KB
Lawfare, The Law of Lying (PNG)6.77 MB
OIG Reply, USPS Tracking738.7 KB
OPR Letter, Jul 15 201985.62 KB
DOJ OPR FAQ Webpage247.42 KB
DOJ OPR Webpage458.03 KB
Continuing Violations Doctrine3.35 MB
Federal Statute of Limitations740.9 KB
Justice Manual, Conspiracy69.81 KB
Doyle, Federal Conspiracy Law659.26 KB
USA Today, Acosta, Epstein, Jul 9 2019345.58 KB
Email Complaint to OPR, Jul 15 201972.58 KB
DOJ Ethics Handbook218.45 KB
OIG Reply, Jul 23 201977.09 KB
OIG Letter, Jul 15 2019718.09 KB
USPS Tracking, Jul 15 2019943.07 KB
USPS Tracking, Jul 23 20196.57 MB
Obstruction of Justice, Elements167.36 KB
U.S. v. Neiswender147.13 KB
U.S. v. Neiswender, Citing Cases287.87 KB
OIG Letter, Jul 31 20194.77 MB
EOUSA Letter, Aug 7 20193.63 MB
EOUSA Letter, Aug 13 2019152.25 KB
Grassley Letter to EOUSA, Sep 17 2014136.43 KB
USPS Tracking, Aug 13 20191.45 MB
LaCedra v. EOUSA311.53 KB
Slate, Apr 26 2019880.39 KB
Email to Criminal Division, Aug 20 201952.5 KB
Letter to CIGIE, Aug 21 201981.14 KB
Letter to CIGIE (email), Aug 21 201979.03 KB
CIGIE Webpage338.21 KB
Follow-up Letter to CIGIE, Aug 22 201996.73 KB
Letter from CIGIE, Aug 23 201987.29 KB
Letter to CIGIE, Aug 26 2019106.69 KB
Letter to CIGIE (email), Aug 26 2019212.07 KB
CRS Report: Federal Inspectors General766.52 KB
Overview of Federal IGs544.21 KB
CIGIE Policies and Procedures282.92 KB
Email to CIGIE-IC, Aug 30 2019106.68 KB
The Ostrich Instruction2.99 MB
Willful Ignorance1.88 MB
Willful Blindness1.92 MB
Principal Agent Knowledge184.68 KB
The Circumlocution Office67.38 KB
Emails with CIGIE, Sep 3 2019353.33 KB
Obstruction of Justice, Georgetown Univ. Law264.29 KB
Inspector General of Federal Courts365.8 KB
Inspector General for Federal Courts1.79 MB
IG Act (of 1978, as amended, 2014)307.54 KB
Additional Complaint Email, Sep 16 2019144.21 KB
CIGIE Quality Standards for Investigations (QSI)525.2 KB
Judge Joseph Amicus Brief491.02 KB
Judges Support Judge Joseph4.15 MB
Salon Whistleblower Article6.46 MB
Techdirt Whistleblower Article2.93 MB
DNI Letter627.96 KB
LawFare Whistleblower Article9.88 MB
IC IG Michael Atkinson1.47 MB
USOGE webpage, Where to Report Misconduct290.33 KB
Letter to OGE, Sep 22 201977.43 KB
Letter to OLC, Sep 23 20191.45 MB
Letter to OLC, Sep 23 2019, Notice of Receipt366.54 KB
OLC Webpage3.34 MB
Han Ye Lee v. Colorado Times255.17 KB
Email, Notice of Case Citation129.19 KB
CRS Report on False Statements and Perjury888.56 KB
CRS Report, Statutory Inspectors General1.42 MB
CIGIE Quality Standards for IGs (Silver Book)333.2 KB
Another Additional Complaint Email, Sep 30 2019109.04 KB
RE: Another Additional Complaint Email129.25 KB
RE: Additional Complaint Email163.3 KB
DOD IG Administrative Investigations Manual1.23 MB
CIGIE Dismissal Letter, Oct 9 2019402.4 KB
CIGIE Dismissal Letter Email, Oct 11 201936.25 KB
Response to CIGIE Dismissal Letter, Oct 12 2019401.14 KB
Response to CIGIE Dismissal Letter Email, Oct 12 201940.26 KB
Email to CIGIE, Oct 18 201947.29 KB
Letter sent to individual IGs1.8 KB
Rot in Hell, Dec 17 201998.75 KB
RotInHell.pdf98.75 KB